Associate Professor Ingvild Saksvik-Lehouillier at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology’s (NTNU) Department of Psychology, states about: “Sleeping less than normal impacts how we feel the next morning. Not in the sense that we have more negative feelings, like being down or depressed. But participants in our study experienced a flattening of emotions when they slept less than normal. They felt less joy, enthusiasm, attention, and fulfillment. We all have different sleep patterns. The point of having the participants sleep at home was to keep everything as similar to daily life as possible. In the imposed sleep deprivation phase, participants crawled under their covers two hours later than they normally did, and had to get up at their usual time”.
Most sleep research is done in laboratories, but Dr. Saksvik-Lehouillier and her research team studied participants who slept at home. The participants first spent seven nights in their own bed and slept as long as they usually do. Three of the mornings they conducted a set of tests. Next, the participants slept two hours less than normal for three nights. On two of the mornings, they went through the same tests. The practical testing took place about an hour and a half after the participants got up – and without having had any coffee. They were shown 365 different pictures with random letters displayed on a computer screen over a period of 14 minutes. If the image did not contain the letter x, they were told to press the space bar, and if there was an x in the image, they were supposed to do nothing.
Scientists tested responsiveness and accuracy. The reaction time went down after the participants had been sleeping deprived, but the error rate went up. It seems that we react more quickly to compensate for lower concentration. Then there’ll be more mistakes. It may be smart to avoid activities that require a high level of accuracy the morning after sleeping less than usual. Previous studies have shown that sleep deprivation may have about the same effect on driving as alcohol does. Whereas the participants performed better and better each day they took the test after sleeping normally, they scored worse on accuracy each day after a night of insufficient sleep. Scientists know that sleep is important for learning. Maybe that’s what they are seeing here.
In the second part of the test, participants answered a questionnaire to identify 20 positive and negative emotions. They didn’t find clear differences when it came to negative emotions, but there were marked differences for the positive ones. Positive feelings scored worse after just one night of reduced sleep and dropped even more after three nights. I think this is a really interesting find. They already know that fewer positive emotions have a major impact on mental health; and that poor sleep is included in virtually all mental health diagnoses. In terms of how long the lack of good feelings lasts after sleep deprivation, the study did not address that, but the research team plans to investigate the duration of this state of mind.
It’s not just in Norway that people are sleeping less than they used to — it’s an international trend, especially for people who work full-time. Generally, people think that since high altitude nations like Norway, Sweden and Finland the famous 6 months light-dark cycle, sleep patterns would be affected as a consequence. This is not the case, since it concerns lifestyle that is getting permanent all around the world. It’s easy for us to go to bed later than we should, especially when we think. Who does not says ‘I just have to finish watching this series’. But we still have to get up to go to work, or study, or deliver our kids to kindergarten. This contributes to getting too little sleep”
Saksvik-Lehouillier explained: “How long we sleep is just part of the picture, but when we sleep is also important. An irregular circadian rhythm can be worse than sleeping too little. Going to bed and getting up at the same time is recommended. I’m concerned for youth. Adolescents have a greater need for sleep and are a vulnerable group. They feel they need to be available online, there are a lot of entertainment temptations – and maybe the cell phone even goes to bed with them. But they still have to get up the next morning to go to school. Sleep deprivation can quickly become an issue. Many teens experience sleep problems during exam times. For them, it may be a comfort to know that studies show that short-term lack of sleep doesn’t affect their ability to reflect and discuss what they’re learning”.
And she continued: “Long-term studies conducted among shift workers who sleep too little over a long period of time show major negative consequences for their health, including a significantly increased risk for diseases such as cancer and diabetes. Sleep is an individual. Not everyone needs to sleep for seven and a half hours every night. And we’re A and B people. Some of us like to stay up until the wee hours, others love to rise and shine early in the morning. The most important thing is how you feel. If you’re in a good mood and alert when you get up, those are indications that your sleep habits are working for you”.
Shorter sleep times aren’t entirely negative either. The body compensates for shorter periods of time with more effective sleep. The time spent awake in bed is also less. Overall, therefore, he findings suggest that sleep quality, rather than sleep duration, should be the primary target for prevention and intervention, with possible effect on psychological functioning in adolescents.
- edited by Dr. Gianfrancesco Cormaci, PhD, specialist in Clinical Biochemistry.
Saksvik-Lehouillier I et al. Sleep 2020 Apr 19:zsaa078.
Sørengaard TA et al. Front Psychol. 2019 Apr 26; 10:901.
Li A, Chen S, Quan SF et al. Sleep. 2020 Jun 17:zsaa120.
Vermeulen M et al. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2020 May 12.